From flaky, buttery pastries to hand-dipped treats and a curated grocery selection — we make everything from scratch, right here in your neighborhood.
Sugar and Spice and Everything Ice started as a simple idea: make food that tastes like it does at home, only better. Every recipe in our kitchen has been tested, adjusted, and perfected until it earned a permanent spot on our shelves.
We bake our breads before dawn, churn our ice cream fresh each morning, and hand-select every grocery item we stock. Nothing sits on our shelves that we wouldn't serve our own family.
Located on South Main Street in the heart of Highlands, we've become a neighborhood staple — the place where regulars know their usual by name, and first-time visitors leave with a box in one hand and a smile on their face.
Every item on our shelves is baked or prepared in small batches. When it's gone, it's gone — and we're already making more for tomorrow.
Bestseller
Buttery croissants, danishes, and hand-rolled pies made with French technique and local ingredients.
Custom Orders
Birthdays, weddings, or just because — we design and bake show-stopping cakes tailored to your occasion.
Seasonal
Creamy, small-batch ice cream in rotating flavors — from classic vanilla bean to bold seasonal specials.
Sourdough, focaccia, brioche, and more — baked before sunrise so your kitchen smells like morning all day.
Hand-picked pantry staples, specialty snacks, and local finds — everything we'd keep in our own kitchen.
Cookie boxes, cupcake assortments, and grazing platters perfect for gatherings, gifts, or treating yourself.
We don't cut corners, and we don't take shortcuts. Here's what you get when you choose Sugar and Spice.
Every loaf, scoop, and pastry is made in limited quantities. Freshness isn't a slogan — it's our operating system.
We're not a chain. We're the bakery on your corner — the one that knows your name and your usual order.
Premium butter, real vanilla, locally sourced eggs. We use the kind of ingredients that make a noticeable difference.
Need a cake for Saturday? A bulk order for the office? Call ahead and we'll make it happen — no question asked.
"The croissants here are unreal — flaky, buttery, and somehow better than anything I've had in the city. We drive from all over just for these."
"Ordered a custom birthday cake and it exceeded every expectation. Beautiful, delicious, and the team was so patient with all my changes. Truly special."
"The ice cream flavors rotate constantly and every single one is incredible. Plus, the grocery section is a hidden gem — found things I couldn't find anywhere else."
Whether it's a quick coffee break, a custom cake order, or a full grocery run, we're here for you. Walk in or give us a call — we'd love to hear from you.
Thanks for reaching out. We'll get back to you within 24 hours.
